You can now order online. Click here

ORDER
ORDER
an abstract photo of a curved building with a blue sky in the background

A Little Taste of New York, Right Here in Orange Park

Real bagels, real flavor, real family. Welcome to Park Avenue NY Bagels.

Our Story

WHY PEOPLE KEEP COMING BACK

Real NY-Style Bagels Chewy and dense — not the soft supermarket kind. Stacked, Not Skimped Generous portions and combinations that make sense, from a classic Bacon, Egg & Cheese to a loaded chopped cheese hash brown bagel.

A Little Taste of New York, Right Here in Orange Park

We're a bagel shop, plain and simple — and we take that seriously. We start with real New York-style bagels and build them into the kind of sandwiches you'd find at a good deli up north: real deli meats, generous portions, and spreads that actually taste like something.

We're not a chain, and we're not trying to overcomplicate it. Whether you're grabbing a quick coffee and a shmear on your way to work or settling in for a loaded breakfast sandwich with the family, this is your neighborhood spot now.

Here's what our customers say

”Hands down best-tasting bagels in Jacksonville! The staff is super welcoming and the New York vibe just adds something special to the whole experience. Honestly 10/10 new favorite breakfast spot.

Food: 5/5 | Service: 5/5 | Atmosphere: 5/5”

- S.A

”We love this place and have been here many times. The food and service are always excellent. I definitely hope this place sticks around. It’s a great addition to this side of town for sure. Bagels are as close as you can get to NYC(minus the water). Favorites are the lox on everything bagel and the sausage, egg, and cheese.

Food: 5/5 | Service: 5/5 | Atmosphere: 5/5”

- J.E

”This spot was truly divine! I just came home from spending my Birthday in New York and haven’t been able to find a bagel that even remotely compares. They nail it 🥰 🥯 A little slice of New York in Florida. Thank you!!!”

- H.G

”Stopped in after wanting to try this place since they opened and man am I disappointed!! Disappointed I didn't go in sooner, holy cow! Everything Asiago with chive cream cheese was a dream but that turkey, bacon, egg, and cheese on Everything Asiago blew me away!! I absolutely will be going back!! The tall young man at the counter was delightful and explained the menu, his favorites, and was just so friendly!

Food: 5/5 | Service: 5/5 | Atmosphere: 5/5”

- C.C

”Service was great and the workers were so friendly! We had a large group and they were so accommodating and the food came out so fast! Food was 10/10”

- K.W

”Been here a couple times, and the service never fails. The best customer service ever! The asiago bagel with bacon & eggs, perfection. The fresh mango juice….. Highly recommended !!!"

Food: 5/5 | Service: 5/5 | Atmosphere: 5/5”

- S.S

READ MORE REVIEWS

”If I could put down ten stars I would! From muffins to bagels this place is delicious. My server was extremely friendly to me. Definitely recommend”

- M.B